Seeing the light in education
Scott Leeder, of VELUX, asks: Are we still in the dark when it comes to daylight design?
Posted by Julian Owen | October 15, 2018 | HVAC & lighting
cundall, arup, education, scott-leeder, velux, daylight-design, design-a-brighter-future

There is nothing quite like the warm glow of a sunrise, the way the afternoon sun plays across a room, or how a single ray of sunlight has the power to transform a space. Yes, the effects of daylight are well known in the architecture community, but are they really understood?

Multiple studies have shown exposure to natural light aids health and wellbeing, increases productivity, improves mood, and even helps to save energy and retain staff. However, these studies have also highlighted a need for a greater focus on daylight design, introducing it earlier in the planning process and more comprehensive government lighting standards.

Natural light is an essential design element

According to Andrew Bissell, Lighting Director at Cundall, daylight design should be a factor from the very outset of any project. Every detail – including location, orientation, daylight exposure, window placement, balance of thermal heating, use of glazing - can influence building comfort.

“Daylight design needs to be involved at the planning stage – any later, and its effect is already limited,” says Andrew. “It’s about how light enters a space, thinking about all the rooms; not just basing it on digital models and numbers, but also lighting patterns and ensuring light is distributed evenly in every space.”

“In my experience, many architects tend to, understandably, base their knowledge of daylight on past projects,” says Laura Phillips, Lighting Designer and Associate Director at Arup. “There is a tendency to shy away from specifying daylight systems, as they can be costly to a project if not considered and integrated early on, and the benefits can be difficult to sell to a client.

“Greater collaboration on daylight quality is needed – early on within the brief – to create buildings that allow daylight to be utilised to its full potential.”

Daylight is a commodity

Daylight, when harnessed correctly, has been shown to have massive energy benefits, offsetting the need for less healthy artificial lighting while cutting energy costs by 30% to 45%.

Decades of research has also shown exposure to daylight throughout the working day can improve mental function – including memory and speed of work – by between 10% and 25%, and improve productivity by up to 15%. It is claimed to have an even greater psychological effect than fresh air.

More access to daylight, and something as simple as having a desk with a view, can also help with staff retention, as employees are shown to be happier and take less sick days.

The artificial versus natural light debate

A lot of new lighting technology has been designed to replicate natural light, but it offers no real benefit. As much as LED and other artificial lighting claims to mimic natural light, it has a very limited spectrum and lacks the naturally occurring colours vital for proper visual performance; also, the regulation of hormones and neurotransmitters in the brain, such as cortisol and melatonin, respectively related to stress and a prerequisite to sleep.

That being said, adequate levels of daylight throughout the day are not always possible, due to the ever-changing position of the sun, window orientation, and other factors.

This is where a greater understanding of daylight design comes in, says Laura: “We work closely with architects and clients to ensure lighting is considered as a whole - both natural and artificial - through detailing and effective lighting controls.”

Layouts need to be designed to balance artificial and natural light - taking into consideration façade reflection, the sun’s movement, glare, shading, light intensity and automation – to ensure spaces are evenly lit, with external and internal elements working together.

Most importantly, lighting needs to suit the function and needs of the occupants of the space. Offices, laboratories, leisure centres and, especially, schools, all have specific requirements.

A new standard for daylight

There is growing demand for more detailed daylight standards and clearer parameters to be introduced to ensure daylight design is implemented at the planning stage. Whilst recent years have seen a positive step change - with the move from daylight factors to climate-based daylight modelling - there is now a need for further changes, such as introducing the spectrum of the light to the matrix, as well as further measurement positions relating to the eye position and viewing direction of occupants.

Andrew says: “We need to move away from current light measuring tools, as they just look at the amount of light and not how it affects occupants. Measures like melanopic lux and circadian stimulus (which seeks to measure both the visual and biological influences of light) and greater clarity on what ‘health lighting’ means need to be made regulatory standards.”

The more we learn about daylight, the more we see the need for professional bodies to influence government to improve standards. More case studies and research are also needed to develop best practices.

Velux’s Design a Brighter Future, to be held in Glasgow next month, will highlight the need for more integrated daylight strategies. Laura Phillips will be speaking there, while Andrew Bissell recently spoke at the event in Manchester: “It is bringing together developers, architects, lighting designers and academics into one room to discuss research and real evidence of how to better utilise daylight and ventilation to build healthier buildings. This is what we need and it can really make a big difference.”

Daylight design is still considered a “non-discipline”, with responsibility for it spread across the design team. Focusing more on the importance of daylight in the built environment is key, and could be taught to a much greater extent at university level. When lighting specialists are appointed to design daylight schemes for galleries and museums, some staggering results are achieved in the process of ensuring works of art are not damaged by lighting. Yet the same level of service is not afforded many regular buildings we use - is our health and wellbeing less important than preserving art?

To find out more about how daylight and ventilation improves human well-being and performance, book your free place at the next Velux: Design a Brighter Future breakfast event. The next events take place in Birmingham (23 Oct) and Glasgow (7 Nov). For more details or to register, please click here

Scott Leeder is Commercial Director at VELUX Modular Skylights

CALL US EMAIL US COLLAPSE